A Greater Goal:

How Courage and Teamwork Changed Women’s Soccer

Courage and solidarity helped generations of women soccer players change the game.

Book Snapshot

Book: A Greater Goal: The Epic Battle for Equal Pay in Women’s Soccer—and Beyond

Author: Elizabeth Rusch

Genre: Young adult narrative nonfiction

Vibe Check: Inspiring, sometimes infuriating, and ultimately hopeful

Best for: Readers interested in equal rights for women, fairness, sports, leadership, and making a difference

Reading time for this review: About 3 minutes

Find the book: Bookshop.org to support independent bookstores or other online booksellers

What would you do if standing up for justice and fairness ended up costing you the chance to compete in the Olympics?

This was the decision facing members of the U.S. Women’s National Soccer Team in 1995. With the 1996 Olympics approaching, nine players challenged unfair terms in their contracts with the U.S. Soccer Federation. The federation responded by cutting them from the Olympic training camp.

These players had spent years pursuing their Olympic dreams. Now those goals were in jeopardy.

This is just one of the many compelling stories Elizabeth Rusch tells in A Greater Goal, an inspiring, and sometimes infuriating, account of women soccer players’ long struggle for equal pay and fair treatment in American soccer.

An Infuriating Pattern

As I read this book, I was repeatedly struck by the unfair differences in the treatment of women compared to men on U.S. soccer teams.

Rusch describes differences in pay, bonuses, coaching, training support, accommodations, and transportation. In one particularly revealing episode, the women’s team was housed in a bed-and-breakfast and transported in a small shuttle bus, while U.S. Soccer housed a men’s youth team competing nearby in a hotel and provided them with a luxury bus.

These weren’t just differences in money. They reflected differences in how the athletes were valued and respected.

What made the situation especially infuriating was that the women’s team was enormously successful. Yet again and again, the players had to fight for fair treatment.

I found myself getting angry at the inequities—and increasingly impressed by the women who refused to accept them.

Courage, Solidarity, and Leadership

The 1995 confrontation particularly stayed with me.

When the nine players were locked out, U.S. Soccer invited other women to participate in the training camp. Among them were Brandi Chastain, who had previously been cut from the national team, and Shannon MacMillan.

Both faced difficult choices. They wanted to support their locked-out teammates, but attending camp might be an important opportunity for their soccer careers. For Chastain, it was a chance to get back in the game.

Chastain called team leader Julie Foudy to explain her dilemma.

Foudy’s response was both characteristic of her leadership and remarkable in its judgment. Rather than tell Chastain and the other players to refuse the invitations, she encouraged them to go, compete well, and help build the future team. But she also made clear that there might come a time when everyone would need to stand together.

What impressed me was Julie’s combination of courage and judgment. These women weren’t simply standing up for themselves. They were thinking about one another, balancing their individual opportunities against shared goals, and building the trust they would need for the struggle ahead.

That’s a powerful picture of leadership and courage.

How Change Happens

The fight for equal treatment continued through generations of players. It involved negotiations, advocacy, legal challenges, and years of persistent struggle. In 2022, the women’s and men’s national teams reached landmark equal-pay agreements with U.S. Soccer.

But the outcome wasn’t guaranteed. The players faced resistance, uncertainty, and considerable personal risks.

For me, that’s one of the most important lessons of A Greater Goal.

Being right isn’t always enough to change an unfair situation. People also need the courage to act, the persistence to keep going, and the ability to organize and work with others.

Rusch brings this lesson to life through the experiences of actual people rather than treating social change as an abstract idea.

Why I Recommend It

I especially recommend A Greater Goal to people interested in equal rights for women, fairness, leadership, and making a difference. Women athletes will find powerful role models in these courageous players, but the lessons about courage, solidarity, and working for change are just as relevant to men. Athletes and sports fans will also enjoy this behind-the-scenes account of an extraordinary team. After all, creating a fairer world isn’t just the responsibility of people experiencing injustice. It’s a responsibility all of us must take on.

But you don’t have to be a soccer fan to appreciate the story.

Yes, these players eventually won an important victory. But what mattered most to me was how they won it.

Their courage and solidarity remind us that entrenched institutions can change, and that ordinary people working together, with courage, creativity, and persistence, can help make that change happen.

*****

Estes, F. (2022). Design Thinking: A Guide to Innovation. I wrote this to help people make changes in the status quo.